Music Of Your Youth

Breaking Up Is Hard To Do – AI Knowledge

Related Pages:
View Full Human Version with Charts & Media →
Browse all AI Knowledge Units →

Summary

“Breaking Up Is Hard to Do” stands as one of the quintessential Brill Building pop songs and Neil Sedaka’s defining recording. Released in June 1962, this two-minute burst of pure pop energy combined sophisticated songcraft with an irresistibly catchy improvised scat vocal hook that would become instantly recognizable across generations. The song’s journey from conception to chart-topper exemplifies the collaborative magic of early 1960s pop music—a partnership between composer and lyricist, enhanced by skilled session musicians and The Cookies’ backing vocals, all captured in a recording that would influence pop music for decades.

Core Facts

Attribute Details
Song Title Breaking Up Is Hard to Do
Artist Neil Sedaka
Writers Neil Sedaka (music), Howard Greenfield (lyrics)
Release Date June 1962
Record Label RCA Victor
Duration 2:18
Genre Brill Building, Doo-wop, Pop
B-Side As Long as I Live
Peak Chart Position (US) #1 Billboard Hot 100 (August 11, 1962)
Background Vocals The Cookies

Timeline

Historical Context

By 1962, the Brill Building in New York City had become the epicenter of American pop songwriting. Teams of composers and lyricists worked in small cubicles, crafting songs that would define the sound of early 1960s radio. Neil Sedaka and Howard Greenfield were among the most prolific of these partnerships, having already produced hits like “Calendar Girl” and “Happy Birthday Sweet Sixteen.”

The song emerged during a transitional period in American popular music—after the initial rock and roll explosion of the mid-1950s but before the British Invasion would reshape the landscape in 1964. This era favored polished, professionally crafted pop songs that blended doo-wop harmonies with sophisticated arrangements. Sedaka drew inspiration from contemporaries including The Everly Brothers’ “Cathy’s Clown” and The Showmen’s “It Will Stand,” while the song’s opening bore an unintentional resemblance to The Fleetwoods’ “Come Softly to Me.”

The involvement of The Cookies as backing vocalists connected the recording to the broader tapestry of early 1960s pop and R&B. This female trio had worked extensively with other Brill Building writers and would continue to be an essential part of numerous hit recordings throughout the decade.

Musical Significance & Innovation

AllMusic’s assessment of the song as “two minutes and sixteen seconds of pure pop magic” captures its essential achievement: maximum emotional and musical impact delivered with remarkable economy. The song demonstrates the Brill Building approach at its finest—every element serves the whole, with no wasted motion.

The most innovative element arose from creative necessity. When Sedaka and Greenfield couldn’t devise lyrics for the intro, Sedaka’s improvised “come-a come-a down, dooby doo down down” became the song’s most memorable feature. This nonsense syllable hook, drawing from doo-wop tradition, proved so effective that Sedaka wanted to use it as backing throughout the entire track. The decision to keep this improvised element showcases how spontaneity could enhance the calculated craft of Brill Building songwriting.

The recording session assembled premier New York session musicians: guitarists Al Casamenti, Art Ryerson, and Charles Macy; pianist Ernie Hayes; bassist George Duvivier; drummer Gary Chester; saxophonist Artie Kaplan; plus a full string section. This combination of rock and roll instrumentation with orchestral sweetening typified the sophisticated “uptown” sound that distinguished Brill Building productions from rawer rock and roll recordings.

Cultural Impact & Legacy

“Breaking Up Is Hard to Do” achieved the rare feat of becoming a significant hit multiple times across different eras. The original 1962 version established it as Sedaka’s signature song, reaching #1 in the United States and Canada while charting internationally in the UK (#7), Argentina (#3), and Australia (#19). It also crossed over to the Hot R&B Sides chart, peaking at #12.

The song’s enduring appeal is demonstrated by its chart success across three different decades. Between 1970 and 1975, three separate versions became top-40 hits: Lenny Welch’s cover, The Partridge Family’s version, and most remarkably, Sedaka’s own 1975 re-recording. The latter version, arranged as a slower ballad, proved that the song’s emotional core could support radically different musical treatments.

The breadth of artists who have covered the song reads like a who’s who of popular music: Paul Anka, The Carpenters, The Four Seasons, Tom Jones, Carole King, Shelley Fabares, and Andy Williams, among many others. Sedaka himself recorded versions in Italian (“Tu non lo sai”) and the song was adapted into French, demonstrating its universal appeal across languages and cultures.

The song’s influence extends beyond cover versions. Its demonstration of how a simple lyrical concept, combined with an irresistible hook and professional craftsmanship, could create timeless pop music served as a template for generations of songwriters. The improvised scat intro became a case study in how spontaneous creativity could enhance carefully planned compositions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who wrote “Breaking Up Is Hard to Do”?

The song was written by Neil Sedaka (music) and Howard Greenfield (lyrics). They were one of the most successful songwriting teams of the Brill Building era, having collaborated on numerous hits including “Calendar Girl” and “Happy Birthday Sweet Sixteen.”

What is the famous scat intro in “Breaking Up Is Hard to Do”?

The iconic “come-a come-a down, dooby doo down down” intro was improvised by Sedaka when he and Greenfield couldn’t think of appropriate lyrics for that section. They liked the spontaneous vocalise so much they kept it in the final recording, and Sedaka even wanted to use it as backing vocals throughout the entire song.

Did Neil Sedaka record “Breaking Up Is Hard to Do” more than once?

Yes, Sedaka recorded two distinctly different hit versions. The original 1962 recording was an uptempo pop song that reached #1. In 1975, he re-recorded it as a slower ballad arrangement, which also became a significant chart hit, demonstrating the song’s versatility and enduring appeal.

Who sang backup vocals on the original 1962 recording?

The Cookies, an influential female vocal group who worked extensively with Brill Building songwriters, provided the background vocals on the original recording.

What songs influenced “Breaking Up Is Hard to Do”?

Neil Sedaka cited several musical inspirations including “It Will Stand” by General Johnson and The Showmen, The Everly Brothers’ “Cathy’s Clown,” and noted an unintentional similarity to “Come Softly to Me” by The Fleetwoods.

How many times did “Breaking Up Is Hard to Do” become a top-40 hit?

Remarkably, the song became a top-40 hit four times: the original 1962 version by Sedaka, cover versions by Lenny Welch (1970) and The Partridge Family (1972), and Sedaka’s own re-recording in 1975.

Did Neil Sedaka record the song in other languages?

Yes, Sedaka recorded an Italian version titled “Tu non lo sai,” which helped endear him to Italian fans. The song was also adapted into French by other artists.

Sources & Verification